DespitepreviouscommentsbyusersIfeelarealittleunfair,thisfilmisoneforfansofBasilRathboneandtheSherlockHolmesseries.RathboneisTHEHolmesandthisisoneofthebestoftheUniversalreleasesoftheperiod.Ok,theplotcanbealittlethinattimes,allthebodiesareidentifiedusingcircumstancialevidencewhichwouldn'tholdupincourt,butbehonest,whenyouwatchthefilmforthefirsttime,whodoyouthinkisresponsibleforthedeathsofTheGoodComrades?Youcertainlyaren'tpreparedfortheending!LikeTheScarletClawandTheHoundOfTheBaskervilles,theBlackandWhiteformatcomplimentsthestorybrilliantlyinhelpingtosetthemood,somethingwhichlaterversionsofSherlockHolmesfilmscannotsadlyre-produce.Whenyouwatchthisfilm,enjoyitandtrynottoanalyseittoomuchoryouwillruinitforyourself.Allinall,afilmyoucansitdownandenjoyagainandagain.